Realogy Sues Compass Alleging Antitrusts Violations - Michael McVinney
Contact Michael McVinney, a NY licensed Real Estate Broker. Michael McVinney is also licensed in PA.
Bemus Point NY condos for sale,Ashville NY condos for sale,Lakewood NY condos for sale,Mayville NY condos for sale,Jamestown NY condos for sale,Falconer NY condos for sale,Ellicotville NY condos for sale,Fredonia NY condos for sale,Chautauqua NY condos for sale,Lakefront condos for sale,Bemus Point NY fsbo,Ashville NY fsbo,Lakewood NY fsbo,Mayville NY fsbo,Jamestown NY fsbo,Falconer NY fsbo,Ellicotville NY fsbo,Fredonia NY fsbo,Chautauqua NY fsbo,Lakefront fsbo,Bemus Point NY home for sale,Ashville NY home for sale,Lakewood NY home for sale,Mayville NY home for sale,Jamestown NY home for sale,Falconer NY home for sale,Ellicotville NY home for sale,Fredonia NY home for sale,Chautauqua NY home for sale,Lakefront home for sale,Bemus Point NY real estate license,Ashville NY real estate license,Lakewood NY real estate license,Mayville NY real estate license,Jamestown NY real estate license,Falconer NY real estate license,Ellicotville NY real estate license,Fredonia NY real estate license,Chautauqua NY real estate license,Lakefront real estate license,Bemus Point NY real estate agent,Ashville NY real estate agent,Lakewood NY real estate agent,Mayville NY real estate agent,Jamestown NY real estate agent,Falconer NY real estate agent,Ellicotville NY real estate agent,Fredonia NY real estate agent,Chautauqua NY real estate agent,Lakefront real estate agent,Bemus Point NY realty,Ashville NY realty,Lakewood NY realty,Mayville NY realty,Jamestown NY realty,Falconer NY realty,Ellicotville NY realty,Fredonia NY realty,Chautauqua NY realty,Lakefront realty,Bemus Point NY for sale,Ashville NY for sale,Lakewood NY for sale,Mayville NY for sale,Jamestown NY for sale,Falconer NY for sale,Ellicotville NY for sale,Fredonia NY for sale,Chautauqua NY for sale,Lakefront for sale,Bemus Point NY homes for sale by owner,Ashville NY homes for sale by owner,Lakewood NY homes for sale by owner,Mayville NY homes for sale by owner,Jamestown NY homes for sale by owner,Falconer NY homes for sale by owner,Ellicotville NY homes for sale by owner,Fredonia NY homes for sale by owner,Chautauqua NY homes for sale by owner,Lakefront homes for sale by owner,Bemus Point NY foreclosed homes,Ashville NY foreclosed homes,Lakewood NY foreclosed homes,Mayville NY foreclosed homes,Jamestown NY foreclosed homes,Falconer NY foreclosed homes,Ellicotville NY foreclosed homes,Fredonia NY foreclosed homes,Chautauqua NY foreclosed homes,Lakefront foreclosed homes,Bemus Point NY real estate school,Ashville NY real estate school,Lakewood NY real estate school,Mayville NY real estate school,Jamestown NY real estate school,Falconer NY real estate school,Ellicotville NY real estate school,Fredonia NY real estate school,Chautauqua NY real estate school,Lakefront real estate school,Bemus Point NY mls listing,Ashville NY mls listing,Lakewood NY mls listing,Mayville NY mls listing,Jamestown NY mls listing,Falconer NY mls listing,Ellicotville NY mls listing,Fredonia NY mls listing,Chautauqua NY mls listing,Lakefront mls listing,Bemus Point NY buying a house,Ashville NY buying a house,Lakewood NY buying a house,Mayville NY buying a house,Jamestown NY buying a house,Falconer NY buying a house,Ellicotville NY buying a house,Fredonia NY buying a house,Chautauqua NY buying a house,Lakefront buying a house,Bemus Point NY townhomes for sale,Ashville NY townhomes for sale,Lakewood NY townhomes for sale,Mayville NY townhomes for sale,Jamestown NY townhomes for sale,Falconer NY townhomes for sale,Ellicotville NY townhomes for sale,Fredonia NY townhomes for sale,Chautauqua NY townhomes for sale,Lakefront townhomes for sale,Bemus Point NY homesearch,Ashville NY homesearch,Lakewood NY homesearch,Mayville NY homesearch,Jamestown NY homesearch,Falconer NY homesearch,Ellicotville NY homesearch,Fredonia NY homesearch,Chautauqua NY homesearch,Lakefront homesearch,Bemus Point NY houses for sale by owner,Ashville NY houses for sale by owner,Lakewood NY houses for sale by owner,Mayville NY houses for sale by owner,Jamestown NY houses for sale by owner,Falconer NY houses for sale by owner,Ellicotville NY houses for sale by owner,Fredonia NY houses for sale by owner,Chautauqua NY houses for sale by owner,Lakefront houses for sale by owner, contact Michael McVinney, Real Estate Broker Michael McVinney, NY Real Estate Broker, NY Real Estate Agent, NY Realtor, Michael McVinney
17795
post-template-default,single,single-post,postid-17795,single-format-standard,bridge-core-1.0.6,ajax_fade,page_not_loaded,,qode-title-hidden,side_area_uncovered_from_content,qode-child-theme-ver-1.0.0,qode-theme-ver-18.2,qode-theme-bridge,qode_header_in_grid,wpb-js-composer js-comp-ver-6.0.5,vc_responsive

Realogy Sues Compass Alleging Antitrusts Violations

There are a few articles on this, some behind paywalls. I am curious what your thoughts are on this matter. I have also found the source filing and provided information so you can search and interpret it yourself.

A few key details TLDR: The claims state that allegedly Compass engaged in illegal and unfair practices, such as:

  • collusive solicitation to engage in price fixing
  • intentional circumvention of non-compete clauses for corporate employees
  • hostile takeovers with predatory pricing
  • false libelous claims from recruiters to agents that Realogy is about to go bankrupt
  • unauthorized access to Realogy's proprietary databases such as LEAR**
  • getting poached agents to change Realogy listings as 'sold' before leaving for Compass, and then relisting those same homes on Compass's site after switching.**

https://therealdeal.com/national/2019/07/10/realogy-slams-compass-with-explosive-suit/

https://www.wsj.com/articles/compass-engaged-in-illegal-activity-realogy-lawsuit-alleges-11562784434

https://www.housingwire.com/articles/49529-realogy-suing-compass-for-unfair-business-practices-illegal-schemes

https://www.inman.com/2019/07/10/breaking-realogy-sues-compass/

https://therealdeal.com/national/2019/07/11/the-juiciest-claims-in-the-realogy-v-compass-lawsuit/

Obviously there are people here from Compass, Realogy, Independent Brokers that have been solicited by Compass, and various other competing brokerages.

Do you have any first hand experience with Compass? Were they positive or negative?

What's your take on the matter? Do any of these claims hold water?

*Reformatted TLDR for Readability

– Tangentially related, but this is an interesting analysis of Compass: https://www.mikedp.com/articles/2019/5/1/inside-compass-part-1-growth-strategies

Edit: I now have a copy of the filing, so I am going to fill in some additional details:

  • The Lawsuit is taking place with the Supreme Court of the State of New York
  • You can search the case here: https://iapps.courts.state.ny.us/nyscef/CaseSearch
  • The Case Number for the case is 653927, obviously the year is 2019
  • **Additional cases referenced substantiating the claims of unauthorized access and manipulation of Reology Listings are Cases 650912-2015 and 652462-2014, both filed in the state of NY
  • **There are also various other cases referenced from other other non Realogy affiliated, NYC competitors suing Compass for stealing confidential information and manipulating proprietary data
  • A case in California is referenced (Zephyr Real Estate vs Urban Compass, Case# CGC-18-568835) where Compass allegedly violated a nondisclosure agreement between the two parties and used the information they gained to poach employees and agents from Zephyr
  • The suit states in the Facts that Compass poached at least 20 senior salaried employees on Realogy, including Branch Mangers and Vice Presidents, whom were all subject to non-soliciation agreements and/or restrictive convenants
  • In the facts, it goes into detail the process by which Compass would intentionally circumvent non-competes – they would grant a 'National Title' to the Employee but have them still operate, recruit, and control the same Region they were previously working in, but may be temporarily be located remotely until the term of the non-compete expired, upon which their Title converted into a State or Regional title and they were relocated back to their original area.
  • Similarly, a strategy that has also occurred to circumvent non-competes is to hire a key Realogy employee for one title, but then have their job duties be entirely different – with those duties being managing Compass offices and recruiting agents.
  • After purchasing a Realogy franchise that was 2 year's into its 10 year franchise agreement, Compass rebranded the website but allegedly purposefully left references to the Realogy franchise in the source code of the website for SEO.
  • Realogy also accuses Compass of various false claims, one of those examples include a Compass recruiter in May 2019 claiming that Realogy had plans to close the prospective recruit's branch office, a claim that Realogy says was fabricated, and that if it weren't, would indicate possession of confidential information.
  • Another false claim allegedly made is a commissioned report from Compass that claims that according to objected third-party research Compass agents grow their business by 20-40% in their first year of switching to Compass. However, the report only included seven agents, and analysis done by Realogy indicates that their Realogy-affiliated agents experience a 'significant decrease in their business in their first year at Compass'.
  • Additional research done by other competitors nationally indicates a decline of productivity in the first six months that an agent goes to Compass.
  • Another alleged false claim is the boast by Compass that they "build all of its own technology and end-to-end real estate services platforms", as per a quote from Robert Refkin: "we build everything in house, and all the tools and support is in house". Furthermore, these exclusive in-house technologies are allegedly used to justify the high valuation multiple for Compass. However, the suit states that Compass's statements are false, as they purchased CRM software maker Contactually rather than develop an in-house CRM, and that they use third-party tech providers such as MailChimp and Mopro.
  • A substantive false claim, if proven to be true, is the promise to agents that "they will get paid on a multitude of referrals, including for title and mortgage services", which is patently provably a false promise because those payments constitute a kickback under RESPA (Real Estate Settlement Procedures Act).
  • Flouting REBNY rules, such as soliciting home owners/sellers to terminate exclusive listings with Corcoran to convert into Compass exclusive listings, advertising and disseminating Corcoran exclusive listing's on Compass's website as if they were Compass listings, and the previously referred manipulation of Corcoran's proprietary listing database
  • Details about the REBNY violations include Compass purposefully misleading homesellers that they have to cancel listings when an agent moves to Compass, and written evidence from an agent recruiter acknowledging to the potential recruit that Compass will pay a fine on the listings they are poaching from Corcoran

For reference, while there are indeed limitations to non-competes, if they are within a reasonable Geographic area or for work of a substantially different nature, or after a reasonable amount of time then it is acceptable. However, the substance of the case discussing noncompetes is that Compass had employees effectively working in the same locations or managing the same locations they were at before, and their job duties were substantially the same.

submitted by /u/Omnias-42
[link] [comments]